User blog comment:Modernmyrmidon/PG Removal Proposal: Max Caulfield/@comment-32059906-20200108142356/@comment-34368001-20200108152323

Ok so I followed that part by saying that sometimes all of the options you could make are for the greater good. Such as blaming Chole, which would be telling the truth, or taking the blame, which would be protecting your friend. Another example is all of the choices you can make when trying to save Kate from committing suicide. My point was that even though sometimes she does things for the greater good, regardless of the choices, it's inconsistent because she can also hypothetically do bad things, such as making fun of Victoria or letting Warren brutally beat up Nathan. There are a lot of parts where we can't consider her to be fully noble/purr good because a lot of the choices she makes that reflect her personality are player choice. It basically plays the player's sense of morality into the equation for the sake of immersion more than it does flesh out Max as a fully good person. A pure good person if you will.