Thread:Mesektet/@comment-27729149-20151002041329/@comment-27729149-20160128022118

You know I hate to say this, but shout tucker does not seem like a cm to me, I do see him as an incredibly despicably hateable character to the max, but not cm worthy, why? Well:

1. Their actions: is what shou did really worthy of cm? The gold toothed Doctor was expirement in on people and killed 12 people, all shou did was combine his daughter with her dog, honestly which sounds more heinous? The homunculi also did much worse, even if shou doesn't have any redeeming qualities his actions aren't nearly as monsterous as their actions.

2. Heinous factor: so murdering alot of innocent people, including a certain little girl of a deranged scientist, and torturing the living shit out of innocents isnt enough to count, but comnpbing your daughter with a dog is? Father did so much worse than him and was far more cruel and he doesn't count? And no being human and being able to not care does not make you more heinous.

3. Screen time: he only appeared for like one episode and we didn't exactly see how far he's willing to go just for science like the gold toothed Doctor. Scare murdered many innocent people and while it is understandable, is still a lot worse than combining a family member with her dog and only for one episode.

4. Is it really that bad: many scientist in many fictional stories have done similar things to their families and even themselves and they aren't considered cms and sometimes they aren't even considered villains, I'm not gonna act like what he did wasn't heinous, but cm worthy? He needs to do a lot more than that to count, even if it is a family member.

I don't care how hateable he is, hatred shouldn't define who is a monster and who isn't, if you disagree with me than that's ok, we all have our opinion, but while I do hate his guts, it's like tomoo from elfen lied, I may hate him and consider him scum, but he just isn't horrible enough.