User blog comment:Player Gammer/PG Proposal: Bilbo Baggins/@comment-2059440-20190908012703

unfortunately Bilbo would fail Pure Good because he stole from Gollum, was tempted to kill Gollum and he became corrupted by the One Ring - now these are minor negative traits compared to his many good deeds and the One Ring is an exceptional force of corruption but these factor can be put against him in the long run.