User blog comment:Kronika X Cetrion/Pure Good Proposal: Rose DeWitt Bukater/@comment-2059440-20190928014540

she was indeed passionate as the entire romance between her and Jack was an affair.. which would disqualify her even without violence.. yes her lover was an abusive sociopath and she deserved much better but she did still engage quite willingly in the affair before she told said ex-lover she was calling things off.. a "pure of heart" would usually wait until they properly break up with someone (even a horrible someone) before engaging in the level of stuff she and Jack got involved in.

young love? sure.. but it still is, in the end, an affair.