The following are works or franchises which have been deemed incapable of having a Pure Good hero, either because they are purely comedic or innocent in nature, little more than shock or controversy, lack a consistent continuity, have some combination of the above, or possess some other factors which make them not conducive to have a Pure Good hero. Creating a Pure Good Proposal for a character from one of these works is forbidden, and anyone who does so will have their proposal immediately deleted and directed to the blacklist. Should they choose to make a proposal for a hero from a blacklisted work a second time, they will be removed from the whitelist.
- 13 Reasons Why
- Aikatsu
- Almost Naked Animals
- Alvin and the Chipmunks (Animated Series)
- American Dad!
- Animal Crossing
- Aqua Teen Hunger Force
- Assassin's Creed
- Alejo y Valentina
- Barney & Friends
- Bear in the Big Blue House
- Between the Lions
- Blue's Clues
- Bluey
- Bob’s Burgers
- Boohbah
- Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul
- Bubble Guppies
- Bunsen is a Beast
- Caillou
- Captain Underpants
- Deadbolt
- Dinosaur Train
- Drawn Together
- Days Gone
- The Fairly Oddparents
- Family Guy and The Cleveland Show
- Futurama
- God of War
- Grand Theft Auto
- The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy
- Happy Tree Friends
- Hetalia: Axis Powers
- HiHi Puffy AmiYumi
- Jake and the Neverland Pirates
- King of the Hill
- Little Bear
- Little Bill
- Little Einsteins
- Looney Tunes (excluding films)
- Love Live!
- Lucky Star
- Maggie and the Ferocious Beast
- Martha Speaks
- Marvin the Tap-Dancing Horse
- Metro
- Minecraft (excluding Story Mode)
- Mr. Pickles
- Ni Hao, Kai-Lan
- Oggy and The Cockroaches
- Peanuts
- Peppa Pig
- Postal
- Postman Pat
- Ren and Stimpy
- Retarded Animal Babies
- Rick and Morty
- Robot Animals
- Sesame Street
- The Simpsons
- South Park
- SpongeBob SquarePants (excluding films)
- Shimmer and Shine
- Super Why!
- Team America: World Police
- Team Fortress 2
- Teen Titans Go!
- T.U.F.F. Puppy
- Teletubbies
- That's So Raven
- The Backyardigans
- The Berenstain Bears
- The Boondocks
- The Loud House
- The Office (both the UK and US versions)
- The Wiggles
- Tom and Jerry (excluding films)
- Uncharted
- Waybuloo
- Where's Waldo?
- Zaboomafoo