Andy in childs play
This article's content is marked as Mature
The page Jimmy Darling contains mature content that may include coarse language, sexual references, and/or graphic violent images which may be disturbing to some. Mature pages are recommended for those who are 18 years of age and older.

If you are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are free to view this page. Otherwise, you should close this page and view another page.


James "Jimmy" Darling is the illegitimate son of Dell Toledo and Ethel Darling. He is a main character in American Horror Story: Freak Show. His condition, ectrodactyly, earned him the stage name Lobster Boy.

He is portrayed by Evan Peters, who also portrays Kit Walker.


Jimmy's deformity has been exploited all his life, beginning with paid admission to the spectacle of his birth. 

Personality and Appearance

Jimmy has short, dirty blonde hair. He favors wearing a white tank top with overalls or motorcycle leathers. 

Jimmy has a strong affection for his fellow freaks and is loyal to those close to him. However, he despises those who see his kind as nothing more than freaks and fights for their acceptance as regular people.


The 'monsters' of Elsa's freak show consider themselves family but that had a more literal meaning for Jimmy, with his strongman father, bearded mother, and hermaphrodite stepmother. He was handsome and rebellious. With gloved hands he was quite the charmer of young women. Ungloved he supplemented his income by offering unique sexual services to the desperate local housewives.

He was disappointed in the failing sideshow business and angered by society's treatment of his kind. He wanted to leave the carnie life and live off the land. However, after saving the twins from arrest by slitting the throat of a detective, he rallied the carnies into a greater bond.

With the police on high alert for one of their own as well as the one responsible for a spree of murder and kidnapping, Jimmy became worried about covering up his crimes and remorseful about taking a life. He began to consider a more compassionate and civil approach to seeking society's acceptance. With the aid of Paul andEve, he inters the detective's dismembered body for incineration, and secures the policeman's badge to find another means of disposal.

Jimmy shot down Dandy Mott's desire to join the troupe by assuring him that it wasn't the life for him and expressing envy for Dandy's affluence and lack of deformity. He was far more encouraging to Dot whom, after Bette revealed her inability to carry a tune, he encouraged to overcome stage-fright and sing with a voice that made both her sister and employer turn green with jealousy.

In his efforts at societal integration, Jimmy brought his fellow freaks into Jupiter for lunch at the local diner. This didn't go over well with the staff and patrons and things just got worse at the arrival of Dell, who chastised them for the public spectacle's detriment to box office. Jimmy's recalcitrance only resulted in a public beating. Humiliated, Jimmy sought the aid of Elsa in taking Dell down. He secured her trust by confessing his murder of the detective to protect the twins and played to her vanity by revealing the subordinate billing Dell gave her on the show's fliyr. They conspired to frame Dell for the murder by planting the badge in his trailer. Unfortunately, the strongman caught wind of the plan and turned the tables, resulting in the arrest of Meep. The geek's arrest, subsequent murder in a jail cell, and disposal at the fairgrounds left Jimmy's spirit broken.

After the arrival of fortune teller Maggie Esmerelda, Jimmy appears to be smitten with her. He attempts to kiss her but she denies his advance. Embarrassed, he chastises himself for hoping that a normal girl, especially one so beautiful, could love a "freak" like him. In the following episode, "Bullseye", when Maggie asks him to run away with her, the two kiss and he agrees to go anywhere with her, but only after he first visits Dandy.

Jimmy visits Dandy Motts' house where he sees the twins, who are eating a banana split on the couch. Gloria states that "[the twins] can leave whenever they want." With this in mind, Jimmy tells the the twins that they know something isn't right with Dandy and that they should come back to the Freak Show with him. Bette, who is in love with Dandy, doesn't want to leave as she has been living luxuriously. Dot convinces her to leave and they leave with Bette saying "I choose my sister, always."

Back at the Freak Show, Jimmy performs a song for Elsa, which he demands be in the show. Then after Elsa says, "Remember who you're talking to," he replies, "I know exactly who I'm talking to: a liar." He confronts her about the twins and Elsa says they "ran off" but Jimmy is quick to remark and says, "We heard your story, I think it's time we heard theirs." The twins walk out and tell Jimmy he misunderstood them and that Elsa did it as a favor for them.

Jimmy is shocked by this and returns to his tent were he is seen cuddling with Maggie. Maggie brings up running away and says "they're never going to leave this place" but Jimmy says "[they] will, it's just not the right moment."


           Ecran Titre d'American Horror Story Heroes

Murder House
Vivien Harmon | Ben Harmon | Tate Langdon | Violet Harmon | Moira O'Hara | Nora Montgomery | Billie Dean Howard

Lana Winters | Kit Walker | Sister Jude | Sister Mary Eunice | Pepper Gayheart | Grace Bertrand | Shachath

Cordelia Foxx | Zoe Benson | Kyle Spencer | Misty Day | Queenie | Nan | Myrtle Snow | Madison Montgomery | Marie Laveau

Freak Show
Elsa Mars | Bette and Dot Tattler | Jimmy Darling | Ma Petite | Amazon Eve | Maggie Esmerelda | Pepper Gayheart | Penny | Meep | Massimo Dolcefino | Sister Mary Eunice

John Lowe | Alex Lowe | Iris | Liz Taylor | Tristan Duffy | Will Drake | Billie Dean Howard

Lee Harris | Matt Miller | Shelby Miller | Monet Tumusiime | Audery Tindall | Priscilla

Rudy Vincent | Winter Anderson

Cordelia Goode | Mallory | Madison Montgomery | Coco St. Pierre Vanderbilt | Zoe Benson | Myrtle Snow | Misty Day | Queenie | Nan | Tate Langdon | John Henry Moore | Violet Harmon | Behold Chablis | Ben Harmon | Vivien Harmon | Billie Dean Howard | Moira O'Hara | Marie Laveau

Brooke Thompson | Benjamin Ritcher | Xavier Plympton | Chet Clancy | Ray Powell | Trevor Kirchner | Donna Chambers | Bobby Ritcher II

American Horror Stories
Coming Soon!

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.

Fandom may earn an affiliate commission on sales made from links on this page.

Stream the best stories.

Fandom may earn an affiliate commission on sales made from links on this page.

Get Disney+