Andy in childs play.jpg
This article's content is marked as Mature
The page Judith Butler contains mature content that may include coarse language, sexual references, and/or graphic violent images which may be disturbing to some. Mature pages are recommended for those who are 18 years of age and older.

If you are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are free to view this page. Otherwise, you should close this page and view another page.

I wanted to give Miranda some notion of stablity: a father figure who was loving and selfless, dependable. Everything Michael wasn't capable of. I hadn't seen him for years, you see. Then, that day, he turned up in Woodleigh Common. I'd tried to stay out of his way. I excepted he'd soon be gone, but he stayed. I had no idea he and Miranda had become so close, his influence over her.
~ Judith Butler revealing her past with Michael Garfield (in the 2010 film)

Judith Butler is a major protagonist of in Agatha Christie's 1969 Hercule Poirot novel, Hallowe'en Party, and the triangonist in its 2010 television film adaptation from Agatha Christie's Poirot.

Judith Butler is the best friend of Mrs. Ariadne Oliver. She is the mother of Miranda Butler and the former lover of Michael Garfield, and moved to Woodleigh Common for years in order to stay away from her former lover that turned out to be an obssessive psychopath. She did not inform anyone that Michael Garfield is Miranda's biological father.

In Agatha Christie's Poirot, she was portrayed by Amelia Bullmore.


Judith Butler had been living in Woodleigh Common for years after leaving her former lover, Michael Garfield, due to being afraid of his psychopathy and obssession over beauty and all of his creations. She left with pregnancy, but she never informed him about Miranda. As her own compensation for her daughter, she also fabricated that her husband was a pilot who was died in an accident even before Miranda was born.

It all changed two years before the story started, when Michael Garfield had arrived in the community of Woodleigh Common. Judith believed he would soon be gone, but he stayed and became the gardener for Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe. Judith also hardly ever noticed that Miranda often went to Mrs. Llewellyn-Smythe's garden and became friends to Michael Garfield.

A year before the story started, Judith met Ariadne Oliver on an Altaltic cruise and rescued her from falling into the sea. This made them best friends since then. Mrs. Butler later took part in the Halloween Party in Mrs. Rowena Drake's house, albeit without Miranda due to the latter was suffering from a cold.

After the murder of Joyce Reynolds, Hercule Poirot arrived in Woodleigh Common under Mrs. Oliver's request, and was welcomed by Judith and Miranda when he arrived in their house. During the investigation, Poirot slowly discovered the hdiden past of Judith Butler, as well as her former romance with Michael Garfield. In the 2010 film adaptation, it was shown that he discovered no sigh of Judith's self-proclaimed husband on any photo inside their house, plus Miranda's close relationship and similarity to Michael Garfield.

Before the finale, Judith never discovered that it was Miranda who happened to see a murder, with the victim was the long-disappeared Olga Seminoff, until Poirot made his crucial discovery and saved Miranda from Garfield. After Poirot's denouement, Judith eventually admitted her past to him and was grateful with Poirot's efforts with helping her and saving her daughter's life.


  • In Agatha Christie's Poirot, Judith took over some of the role from Superintendent Spence, Nicholas Ransom and Desmond Holland in the novels to serve as the adaptation's triangonist as well as its secondary ally to Poirot. In addition, Poirot deduced the relationship between Judith and Garfield after finding no trace of Judith's (fabricated) husband in her family photos, whilst in the novel there was no explanation to this.


Agatha Christie's signature.png Heroes

Main Detectives
Hercule Poirot | Jane Marple
Secondary Detectives
Parker Pyne | Mr. Quin | Tommy and Tuppence Bresford
Amateur Detectives
Colonel Johnnie Race | Superintendent Battle | Bobby Jones | Frances Derwent | Arthur Calgary | Reniseb | Charles Hayward | Mark Easterbrook

Righteous Culprits
Mary Debenham | Princess Natalia Dragomiroff | Hector MacQueen | Edward Masterman | Colonel John Arbuthnot | Linda Arden | Count Rudolph Andrenyi | Countess Helena Andrenyi | Greta Ohlsson | Pierre Michel | Antonio Foscarelli | Hildegarde Schmidt | Cyrus Hardman | Edith de Haviland | Hercule Poirot
Short Stories
Madame Déroulard | Ronnie Oglander

Supporters, Victims & Others
Captain Arthur Hastings | Inspector Japp | Felicity Lemon | Ariadne Oliver | George the Butler | Superintendent Spence | Colonel Johnnie Race | Superintendent Battle | Countess Vera Rosakoff | Raymond West | Joyce Lemprière
Victims & Attempted Victims
Alexander Bonaparte Cust | Miranda Butler | Mrs. Otterbourne | Pilar Estravados | Olga Seminoff
Bella Duveen | Colonel Carbury | Dr. Stavros Constantine | Dr. Gerard | Dulcie Duveen | Ginerva Boynton | Hori | Judith Butler | Lydia Lee | Miss Bulstrode | Monsieur Bouc | Monsieur Giraud | Nadine Boynton | Rosalie Otterbourne | Sarah King | Sophia Leonides | Stephen Farr | Tim Allerton | Valerie Saintclair | Virginie Mesnard

Adaptational, Homage & Non-canonical
Benoit Blanc | Marta Carbera | Linda Drysdale

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.