Voting

When voting yes on your Pure Good Proposals: I will put in a brief summary of their general heroism and justify their corrupting qualities if they have any.

When voting no on your Pure Good Proposals: If they fail the admirable standard, I will list their most heroic action and why it pales in comparison to other heroes. If they have disqualifying corrupting qualities, I will detail them and why it hinders on them being pure good.

When voting abstain on your Pure Good Proposals: I will list reasons they could count and reasons they couldn't count and list why I am not sure, whether it because of a work's admirable standard or the corrupting qualities of the hero.

  • When the Bold typeface is used, it means I have seen the work.
  • When the Italic typeface is used, it means I have not seen the work in a long time.
  • When the Regular typeface is used, it means I have not seen the work at all.

Note: The Bold typeface and the Regular typeface can be used for the same work if spans multiple episodes or chapters and I have not finished the work. The Bold typeface will be used if a character appears in a part of the work I have seen and the Regular typeface will be used if a character appears in a part of the work I haven't seen.

Proposing

When I propose a character for the Pure Good category, I make sure to make the proposal detailed and persuasive, while still maintaining honesty by not flanderizing the characters in the proposals. When I propose a character for removal from the Pure Good category, I list my concerns about why they probably shouldn't be in the category. I use the default format when proposing characters at all.

If you disagree with the proposal, go ahead and vote against it. While I will be slightly disappointed, having a proposal be rejected is part of the learning process.

Pure Good Proposals
Article Outcome Reason (if rejected) For Against Undecided Link
Chidi Anagonye Approved n/a 4 0 0 Pure Good Proposal: Chidi Anagonye
Fix-It Felix, Jr. Rejected Failing the admirable standard 0 8 2 Pure Good Proposal: Fix-It Felix, Jr.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.