With my birthday coming up this Friday, October 15, I decided to create a Pure Good Proposal for a character of one of my favorite films from my childhood. Hopefully, I think this man may qualify. Without further ado, here's Dr. Doppler from Disney's Treasure Planet.
- 1 What is the Work?
- 2 Who is He? What has he done?
- 3 Corrupting Factors
- 4 Admirable Standard
- 5 Final Verdict
Disney's Treasure Planet is a science-fantasy animated film released on November 27, 2002. The film is based on Robert Louis Stevenson's 1883 novel Treasure Island, albeit with most of the characters except Jim Hawkins and his mother Sarah being replaced with aliens or robots. The film is amazing, as it combines both traditional 2-D animation with 3-D CGI into its characters and env…
Hello Everyone, Emeraldblade95 here with a follow-up announcement addressing issues brought up by users from the last announcement I posted a few weeks ago.
Recently, The Humble Nintendo Master messaged me about a concern that has been going since Pure Good Proposals first started in 2019. In the message, HNM states that every once in a while, there is a PG Proposal for a character who originates from a rather obscure work, one that isn't very well-known by most people. Users such as SpaceProtagonist and Invisible Hover tend to do this expecting people to vote in the hopes that their proposals conclude with a decent consensus, but in many of these proposals, next to no one votes.
Now I know what many of you are thinking, "I don't know the …
Hello everyone, Emeraldblade95 here with another post discussing some recent issues and changes on the site. Many of these issues were brought up by various site users, so I've decided to create the announcement you see here to help everyone get a better understanding of what's been going on lately.
Without further ado, let's begin...
- 1 Invalid Votes
- 1.1 New Blacklist Penalties
- 1.2 Edit-Spamming to Reach 100+ edits
- 2 Wardrobe Infobox Images
- 3 Category Abuse
- 4 Site Background Update
- 5 PG Rejected Template
Since the beginning of the year, I have noticed an unsettling increase in the number of invalid votes, mainly by users who haven't met the criteria yet; in one case, I've caught a user joining the site just to vote on said proposals. As a result of this…
Hello once more, Emeraldblade95 here with the fourth and final installment of my reevaluation of past proposals have have made. For this occasion however, instead of doing a removal of a character that was approved, I will be doing a proposal for a character I had rejected back when rejection proposals were allowed on the site under normal circumstances. But who will be this candidate? Why none other than Chai Xianghua from the Soul Calibur series.
This was one of my first removal proposals I made when PG proposal were introduced nearly two years ago. I made some good points as to why she shouldn't qualify for the category, but I also realized I left out much of the information about her, some of which might actually allow her to qualify fo…
Alright, here is the third entry in my series of revaluations of past proposals and removals I made, as well as the final one that is a removal proposal (the final one will be a proposal, but let's not jump ahead. This time, we will be reexamining Hildegard von Krone from the Soul Calibur series.
This proposal is the most recent in terms of when it was made: being originally created back in July of last year. It only received a minimal 3 votes: 2 yes's and one no in total (the latter vote of which was from a user that is now permanently blocked). Anyways, there is a corrupting factor about Hilde her that I think is disqualifying.
Once again, while her target article isn't necessarily a stub, I recommend using her article on the Soul Calibur W…