Pure Good Removal Proposal: Kanan Matsuura
Second last of the Love Live removals, and this time it will be none other than Kanan Matsuura from Love Live! Sunshine (original proposal). Unlike most of the removals I've done so far, Kanan is a unique case, as she has a unique admirable act that makes her stand out, but still fails the standard, which will be explained in the proposal, as to why she still does not qualify.
Special thanks to Emeraldblade95 for granting me the permission to do this PG Removal.
With that being said, let's start.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is Kanan?
- 3 Why Kanan does not Qualify?
- 4 Verdict
Love Live! Sunshine!! is a 2015 anime of the Love Live series, which is a spin-off of the original 2013 anime Love Live! School Idol Project. Similar to its predecessor, the show focuses …
Pure Good Removal Proposal: Kumin Tsuyuri
So, we look at another PG Removal candidate today, and that is none other than Kumin Tsuyuri (originally proposed by Kittycatgirl1998 0.2) from Love, Chunibyo, and Other Delusions.
Now, what is the issue here? The issue is that Kumin is another case-in-point example of a PG who only does basic, bog-standard actions, as well as showing acts of generic kindness, which is not enough for a show with a low admirable standard. These will be explained through the proposal.
Special thanks to Jester of chaos (Proof of Permission) for giving me the permission to do this removal proposal.
Let's start for today's removal.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is Kumin?
- 3 Why Kumin does not Qualify?
- 4 Verdict
Love, Chunibyo, and Other Delusions is a romantic cmedy light novel s…
Pure Good Removal Proposal: Riko Sakurauchi
Welcome to another series of PG Removals and re-evaluations, where we talk about another candidate in mind: Riko Sakurauchi from Love Live! Sunshine!!. The original proposal was made back in August 2020 by Tatiana Cortez and was later subsequently approved.
After further re-evaluation of the original proposal, most, if not all, of Riko's heroism is considered bog-standard and a form of generic nice, where it will be explained further in this Removal Proposal.
Special thanks to Emeraldblade95 for granting me the permission to do this PG Removal.
With that being said, let's start.
- 1 What's the Work?
- 2 Who is Riko?
- 3 Why Riko does not Qualify?
- 4 Verdict
Love Live! Sunshine!! is a 2015 anime of the Love Live series, which is a spin-off of the original 2013 a…
Pure Good Removal Proposal: You Watanabe
As the mass PG cleanups have been happening this year, I've decided to continue the endeavour of re-evaluating PG approvals that have been done in the past, and a perfect potential PG Removal candidate has come to my mind: You Watanabe from Love Live! Sunshine.
With an empirical analysis of You's PG page, as well as the original proposal's contents from the original proposer, with help of others, it is easily noticeable that most of You's admirable acts fall into bog-standard and generic nice, which does not always qualify enough as PG. All of these will be explained in this Removal Proposal.
Special thanks to Emeraldblade95 for granting me the permission to do this PG Removal.
With that being said, let's start this Removal Proposal.
- 1 What's t…
Standard Pure Goods
Hello, Thehumilator23 here. Now you wonder what this blog post is all about, as this is not the usual standard PG and/or PG Removal Proposals blog post. Instead, we're going to talk about the biggest elephant in the room: Pure Goods. But more rather, it will list and explain the following PG characters listed below are considered bog-standard or do acts of generic heroism within the material that was given. These are known as Standard Pure Goods.
Not a long time ago, Koko Nigel and myself have been pointing out regarding Standard PG characters, and how these types of characters often do not reach beyond the given admirable standard to be counted as Pure Good. Reasons include bog-standard acts, generic heroism, or the source material being t…